Best Rated Nursing Homes in Columbus, OH

The 25 highest CMS-rated nursing homes in Columbus, OH, ranked using official Medicare star ratings (top: 5/5). Free ratings, addresses and phone numbers — n…

Ranked by CMS overall star rating

  1. HIGHBANKS CARE CENTER — CMS 5/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 111 LAZELLE ROAD EAST · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  2. Majestic Care of Columbus LLC — CMS 5/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 44 S SOUDER AVE · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  3. MOHUN HEALTH CARE CENTER — CMS 5/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 2340 AIRPORT DR · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  4. SCIOTO POINTE — CMS 4/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 740 CANONBY PLACE · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  5. CROWN POINTE CARE CENTER — CMS 3/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 1850 CROWN PARK COURT · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  6. FOREST HILLS CENTER — CMS 3/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 2841 EAST DUBLIN-GRANVILLE ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  7. MCNAUGHTEN POINTE NURSING AND REHAB — CMS 3/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 1425 YORKLAND ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  8. RIVERVIEW — CMS 3/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 3710 OLENTANGY RIVER ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  9. WILLOW BROOK CHRISTIAN HOME — CMS 3/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 55 LAZELLE RD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  10. ALLBRIDGE REHABILITATION AND NURSING CENTER — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 5500 EAST BROAD STREET · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  11. BELLA TERRACE REHABILITATION AND NURSING CENTER — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 1520 HAWTHORNE AVENUE · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  12. CAPITAL CITY GARDENS REHABILITATION AND NURSING CE — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 920 THURBER DRIVE WEST · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  13. COLUMBUS ALZHEIMER'S CARE CTR — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 700 JASONWAY AVENUE · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  14. COLUMBUS HEALTHCARE CENTER — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 4301 CLIME ROAD NORTH · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  15. EASTLAND REHABILITATION AND NURSING CENTER — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 2425 KIMBERLY PARKWAY EAST · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  16. EMBASSY OF WOODVIEW — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 2770 CLIME ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  17. NEW ALBANY CARE CENTER — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 5691 THOMPSON ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  18. SAPPHIRE REHABILITATION AND CARE CENTER — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 1605 NORTHWEST PROFESSIONAL PLAZA · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  19. THE LAURELS OF GAHANNA — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 5151 NORTH HAMILTON ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  20. THE LAURELS OF WALDEN PARK — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 5700 KARL ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  21. WEST PARK CARE CENTER LLC — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 1700 HEINZERLING DRIVE · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  22. WEXNER HERITAGE HOUSE — CMS 2/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 1151 COLLEGE AVENUE · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  23. LAURELS OF WEST COLUMBUS, THE — CMS 1/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 441 NORTON ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  24. MAYFAIR VILLAGE NURSING CARE C — CMS 1/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 3000 BETHEL RD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month
  25. SCIOTO REHABILITATION & CARE CENTER — CMS 1/5 overall · COLUMBUS · 433 OBETZ ROAD · est. $4,000–$6,200/month

How this Columbus ranking is built

Every facility above is a Medicare-certified nursing home in the Columbus, Ohio area. Ratings come straight from the CMS Provider Data Catalog — the same dataset behind Medicare's Care Compare — and are refreshed as CMS republishes them. Placement is determined by the overall star rating alone; no facility can pay for a higher position, and names, addresses and phone numbers are free to view.

Columbus nursing home questions, answered

Which nursing homes in Columbus have the highest CMS ratings?

The ranked list on this page is built directly from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services overall star rating for every certified nursing home we track in the Columbus, Ohio area, currently 25 facilities. Facilities are ordered by overall star rating first, then by the number of rating components CMS has published. No facility can pay to appear higher.

What does a CMS 5-star rating actually mean in Columbus?

CMS scores every Medicare-certified nursing home from 1 to 5 stars on three components — health inspections, staffing hours per resident per day, and quality measures — then combines them into an overall rating. Five stars means "much above average" relative to other facilities nationally and within Ohio. It is a relative ranking, not a safety guarantee, so read the inspection history on each facility page before deciding.

What is the average nursing home rating in Columbus?

Across the CMS-rated nursing homes we track in Columbus, the average overall star rating is 2.52/5. Anything at 4 or 5 stars is above the local average; 1 and 2 star facilities are worth reviewing inspection-by-inspection before touring.

Are these Columbus rankings paid placements?

No. Clear Care Connect ranks purely on published government data. We do not accept payment for position, and every facility name, address and phone number on this site is free to view. Only the deep report — full inspection history, deficiency citations, penalties, fire safety records, staffing detail and amenities — costs $9.99.

Other metros

All Ohio facilities · Ohio Medicaid eligibility estimator · Ohio senior care costs

Clear Care Connect